Which is your Favorite?

[RyokoTenchi]

i chose Kanon Just because it is the only one of the three i have played... and the music androcks... and Because i Love Ayu-Chan ^^

[thecrackdealer]

Originally Posted by Weave

and here I was thinking I was the only Minagi fanboy.

I like Minagi the best in Air too. :) I've played both and I like Air slightly better.

For the poll, I'll have to pick other(blasphemy, I know ^_~). Ever17 -the out of infinity- is the best bishoujo game I have ever played. Awesomely deep storyline with great characters. The only thing not as good as Air is the music. KIDS is just about as good of game developers as Key IMO.

[Yuu]

Going back to the homosexuality thing in Clannad (spoiler rot13'd) -
Gurer VF na raqvat jurer Gbzbln erwrpgf nyy bs gur tveyf naq raqf hc tbvat bhg bs punenpgre naq (sbeprshyyl) qngvat Fhabunen. Vg'f gur onq raqvat sbe gur Fhabunen fpranevb gubhtu.

As far as weak writing and characters go, most people tend to think that's because the writer (Kai) who was responsible for those scenarios (Kyou, Kappei, and I think Yukine) was a total hack.

There's an interview in Techgian 7 with Maeda, Kai, and Suzumoto regarding there thoughts about Clannad. Surprisingly, they didn't mention anything about the After scenario.

[Haeleth]

Hope you'll forgive the edit!

Interestingly enough, I didn't think Kyou's scenario was that bad... maybe a bit predictable, but she has some nice lines. Haven't played Yukine's yet.

It's Sanae who really disappointed me, she just didn't seem up to the standard of Key mothers like Akiko and Haruko. I guess she's just overshadowed a bit by her husband...

[Yuu]

Not a problem.

Also, it should be Dengeki Hime not Techgian. Eep.